It's Time to Ban Rubber "Safety" Surfacing

Posted
Tue, 03/03/2015 - 1:01pm
Last updated
5 months ago
1 views
Time to
read
2’
Rubber mats under swings

I find it very odd, and I suspect that you do too, that after more than two decades of allegedly improving playground safety through mandated standards we have essentially the same annual number of accidents.  How can that be?

Certainly some of the standards, such as those for head entrapment and entanglement, will have prevented some injuries, but the types of accidents for which these were developed were always rare. The vast majority, some 85%, of injuries comes from falls.  Nowadays virtually every playground has some form of safety surfacing, so if this mandate was effective, then we should see a significant improvement in accident rates, but we don’t.

There is a simple reason why: rubber surfacing increases injuries. How can this be so?

1.   Rubber safety surfaces do not provide sufficient attenuation.

Engineered wood fiber (EWF) provides more than twice the fall attenuation of even the best mat systems. To my knowledge we do not have an analysis of fall accidents that tells us what type of surfacing was in place. Given the cost of surfacing and the importance of child safety, not having such basic information is just plain appalling.

2.   Rubber safety surfaces create rebound injuries.

Because of the way in which rubber deforms and then bounces back, the brain hits the inside of the skull first on the down stroke and then on the rebound. Neurosurgeons tell us that the rebound damage is often much worse than the initial impact. EWF significantly increases the amount of time impacts are absorbed and have negligible rebound.

3.   Rubber safety surfaces create long bone injuries.

It has long been know in the playground surfacing industry that the fall attenuation standards do not address broken arms and legs. The assumption is that if the worst-case situation, head trauma, is taken care of, that other less critical injuries will also be ameliorated.  Clearly, this is not the case. Again without a statistical analysis comparing rates of injuries by material type, it is difficult to be conclusive, but it appears that both in better fall attenuation plus the ability to prolong impact forces gives EWF a distinct advantage.

The best study I have seen in this area is: Impact attenuation – The case for natural materials. This is a pretty tough read but is well researched and supports the positions presented here.

Increased Injury Rates

The logical conclusion is that any improvement in safety that EWF has been able to provide is negated by the injuries that rubber surfaces introduce.

Without well-done accident and injury data we don’t know this for a proven fact, but the trends are very suggestive. Until proper science can be applied to this critical question I call for a moratorium on the use of rubber playground surfacing except in those areas where EWF becomes displaced with use, such as the bottom of swings, and for accessible routes of travel to transfer stations.

Photo: Everlast Rubber Mulch

Author

Confessions of a Playground Guru

Called by many as one of the “fathers of the modern playground,” Jay began designing unique play environments in 1970. As new materials came into use early in the...

There are 2 Comments

Jerry Cooper's picture

We have long anecdotally known this to be the case, and so it is good to see the arguments being drawn up at last to challenge this expensive and ineffectual 'safety' Leviathan.

Shannon's picture

Thanks for your article. Curious if anyone has looked into any additional injuries resulting from the surfaces used? I actually broke my ankle Sunday (lateral malleolus fracture, of the fibula) as my rubber soled shoe 'caught' on the rubber mat while on a swing. Stopped my foot solid, and snapped my ankle. Yes, seriously.

Seems like in the good old days of dirt and rocks, there'd be less sticking.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.