fbpx A Matter of Human Rights

A Matter of Human Rights

Mon, 06/13/2016 - 3:49pm
Last updated
7 months ago
Time to
hard basketball bankshot

Despite the ADA and IDEA, communities continue to invest rather large sums and space allocations into exclusionary recreation facilities with little or no concern for the differently-able. Individuals with autism, or using wheelchairs, others with mobility limitations and the like are left out as out-of-luck outsiders. When all would like to participate, they experience ramps to exclusion.

Total-Mix Sports diversity based on Universal Design as a concept is ignored.

One would think that human rights considerations would generate the expectation that a community provide for all its inhabitants and not only the non-disabled. The non-disabled can, at any time, gain access to the recreational facilities. The differently-able must wait for a program. The non-disabled can wait for next at basketball, tennis, volleyball, etc. and any and all sports played against others which fact reduces and excludes atypical populations of participants.

Why is no facility offered where participants recreate alongside, not against others? Alongside allows immediate access and requires no contest, no conflict, no competition. Playing alongside means playing without barriers; it accommodates all segments of a population including seniors, children, wheelchair participants, gifted athletes and anyone who likes to play ball. And ball playing receives the funds, the space and our time at recreation as no other community facilities we build to service our citizens.

The following is a testimony in response to Bankshots Court in Montgomery County

My name is Larry R. and I’m an accountant with a practice in Montgomery County and I am blessed with two children, two sons who are autistic, or more properly, on different stages of the autistic spectrum. The two boys love to play ball as do their parents with them. But when I take the family to a park such as the new one being built in Silver Spring, and indeed all other parks in Montgomery County, it nearly breaks our hearts.

At every one of these parks, you can see at once that there are plenty of ballplaying facilities for typical children. The average youngster or teen can wait in line to play tennis, basketball, soccer and the rest. But these are all team sports with opponents. They are not independent or individualized sports so that my boys can drop-in and participate along with everyone else in the community. This is understood as mainstreaming which, apart from programs which have further segregated and segment differently able populations, does not exist.

Why do all the typical kids get ballplaying facilities so much so that many of them are empty like the tennis courts being built for fewer and fewer participants. The point is there are many drop-in facilities: sports courts and sports fields for everyone but not for kids who are physically and cognitively challenged or mobility impaired or in wheelchairs or have other disabilities. They too should have drop-in ball playing sports to drop in with their family to play together and interact with others. There are none. What’s the point of a ramp leading to discrimination and exclusion which characterizes the new Silver Spring Park designed with little thought to including the differently able. They are neglected willfully by a kind of callous indifference on the part of the authorities.

It’s very sad and I speak not only for my own family. I’m certain i speak also for many of Montgomery County’s differently able children and adults who would also like to play ball at a facility but not with opponents, and not with teams, “a sport that does not require offense and defense but actively move their bodies, and are presented with sports challenges that they can succeed at, that socialize and mainstream’s all populations. We need to be giving consideration to diversity and the integration of special populations into a community activity. These Montgomery parks offer accessibility when they should be offering inclusion.” {www.nareletsplayfair.org}

The only glimmer of hope is that of the Bankshot court in King Farm Rockville that brings a community together and includes the differently able. I wish officialdom would visit some weekend. Why so few of these and others like it? There ought to be many such affordances in the community addressing the needs of the total community rather than merely the jocks and athletes. All families blessed with all kinds of children should have drop-in facilities to play ball just like other typical children and not always aggressive and having to defeat rivals but by playing alongside one another, not against one another, where, as I heard said, “you don’t have to win to be a winner,” [NARE] Rather, it is participation alongside others in mainstreaming disabled that brings a community together. There are many of us who would like to see attention paid to those who are so underserved in our parks. The parks of M.C. from the perspective of my family and many others are sadly disappointing.


Reeve Robert Brenner is not your average rabbi. Your average rabbi's signature is not on his own line of basketballs, as Brenner's is. And even if it were, your average rabbi probably couldn't keep one of...